What to Expect in a FINRA Investigation
A Financial Industry Regulatory Authority (FINRA) investigation represents a significant event for any broker-dealer, registered representative, or financial firm.
As a self-regulatory organization (SRO), FINRA has broad authority to examine conduct, enforce rules, and impose sanctions.
A FINRA investigation may include requesting documents (Rule 8210) and possibly conducting On-the-Record (OTR) interviews under oath.
It can originate from various sources, such as complaints or tips, leading to outcomes such as case closure, settlement (AWC), or formal complaints, all of which require cooperation, legal advice, and careful management of sensitive information to address potential career consequences.
Expect a lengthy, confidential process that will require you to provide your employment history, communications, and detailed transaction records. This process demands diligence and may involve other parties such as customers or former employers.
When an investigation also involves the suspicion of a federal crime, the stakes become substantially higher. Understanding the process is critical for navigating the inquiry and protecting your rights and career.
A skilled federal criminal defense attorney with experience in FINRA investigations can help protect your interests during the process.
Key Takeaways
- Every year, the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority (FINRA) prohibits hundreds of broker-dealers and individual brokers from engaging with retail investors.
- FINRA performs investigations under Rule 8210 to initiate enforcement proceedings.
- Violations of Rule 8210 are the leading cause of disciplinary actions against individual brokers.
- Broker-dealers and individual brokers involved in FINRA investigations need to handle their situations very cautiously.
- They must not only take appropriate measures to safeguard themselves during the investigation and respond to the complaint underlying FINRA's inquiry, but also exercise extreme caution to avoid violating Rule 8210.
- Defending against a FINRA investigation involves unique challenges, particularly those related to complying with Rule 8210.
- When informed of an investigation, it is essential to respond promptly and proactively. Efforts to comply with Rule 8210 and develop a strong defense should start right away.
The Stages of a FINRA Investigation
FINRA investigations typically follow a structured progression. While each case is unique, the following common steps provide a roadmap of what to anticipate.
The Triggering Event
An investigation does not begin in a vacuum. It is usually initiated by a specific event that raises a red flag for regulators.
These triggers can include a formal customer complaint, disclosures on a Form U4 or U5, findings from a routine FINRA examination, or a whistleblower tip.
Other common catalysts include referrals from regulatory bodies such as the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) and unusual trading activity detected through market surveillance.
At this initial stage, the subject of the inquiry may not yet be aware that an investigation is underway.
Informal Inquiry
FINRA may start by quietly gathering information. This phase often involves reviewing the firm's books and records, examining internal communications such as emails and text messages, and interviewing supervisory personnel.
While this stage is considered informal, it can quickly escalate to a formal proceeding.
Rule 8210 Request for Information
The issuance of a request under FINRA Rule 8210 marks a critical turning point. This rule grants FINRA the authority to compel a firm or individual to produce documents and information or provide testimony.
A Rule 8210 request can require the production of nearly any relevant document, from emails and recordings to detailed written explanations of conduct.
Failing to comply with a Rule 8210 request can result in an automatic bar from the securities industry.
Furthermore, because FINRA is not a government entity, the Fifth Amendment right against self-incrimination does not apply.
Any statements made or documents produced can be used against you in a FINRA enforcement action and may be referred to law enforcement for use in a parallel criminal case.
On-the-Record (OTR) Testimony
If requested, you will be required to provide sworn testimony in a proceeding similar to a legal deposition.
This On-the-Record (OTR) testimony is recorded and transcribed. Attorneys from FINRA's Department of Enforcement will ask questions on topics such as sales practices, investment suitability, outside business activities, and supervision protocols.
Your legal counsel may be present but has a limited role.
The Wells Notice
If FINRA staff believe rule violations have occurred, they may issue a Wells Notice. This document serves as a formal notification that FINRA is considering bringing disciplinary action.
The notice will outline the potential violations, giving you an opportunity to respond with a "Wells Submission." This response is a chance to present your side of the story and argue why charges should not be filed.
Potential Penalties and Criminal Referrals
If a FINRA enforcement action proceeds, penalties can range from fines and suspensions to a permanent bar from the securities industry.
However, when the underlying conduct also constitutes a potential federal crime, such as wire fraud, mail fraud, insider trading, or securities fraud, the consequences are far more severe.
FINRA regularly cooperates with the Department of Justice (DOJ) and other law enforcement agencies.
Information gathered during the FINRA investigation, including OTR testimony, can be shared and used as evidence in a federal criminal prosecution. A criminal conviction can lead to substantial prison time, massive fines, and restitution orders.
The Role of a Federal Criminal Defense Attorney
Engaging a federal criminal defense attorney at the first sign of a FINRA investigation is essential, particularly when criminal conduct is suspected. An experienced attorney can provide critical guidance through every stage.
During the investigation, they can manage communications with FINRA, assist in responding to Rule 8210 requests to avoid inadvertent admissions, and prepare you for OTR testimony.
They can also craft a compelling Wells Submission to persuade FINRA to drop or reduce the charges potentially.
Should the matter be referred for criminal prosecution, your attorney's role becomes even more vital. They will build a defense strategy tailored to the specific charges. Possible defenses in federal securities fraud cases may include:
- Challenging Intent: Arguing that the prosecution has insufficient evidence to prove intent to commit fraud or wrongdoing.
- Good Faith Defense: Demonstrating that the accused acted in good faith based on the information available at the time.
- Materiality of Misrepresentations: Arguing that any alleged misrepresentations were not material or significant enough to influence decisions.
- Lack of Evidence: Highlighting gaps or weaknesses in the prosecution's evidence, such as unreliable witness testimony or incomplete documentation.
- Procedural Violations: Identifying any procedural errors or violations of rights during the investigation or evidence collection process.
- Reliance on Expert Advice: Showing that the accused relied on the advice of legal or financial experts, which negates intent to defraud.
- Absence of Harm: Arguing that no actual harm or loss occurred as a result of the accused's actions.
An attorney can also negotiate with prosecutors for a potential plea agreement or, if necessary, defend your rights vigorously at trial. For a case evaluation, contact our federal criminal defense lawyers at Eisner Gorin LLP.
Related Content: