Federal Crime of Insurance Fraud – 18 U.S.C. § 1033

18 U.S.C. § 1033 makes certain fraudulent conduct within the insurance industry a federal crime when the activity affects interstate commerce.

Federal insurance fraud cases are often complex, document-heavy investigations that can carry penalties of up to 15 years in federal prison.

Unlike many state insurance fraud cases, Section 1033 focuses heavily on misconduct by insurance company employees, officers, agents, and individuals engaged in the business of insurance.

However, the statute can also apply to individuals who make materially false statements to influence regulatory actions.

If you are under federal investigation for insurance fraud, early legal intervention is critical.

Your best hope for a favorable outcome is with an experienced criminal defense attorney at Eisner Gorin LLP. To schedule a consultation, call (818) 781-1570 or contact us here.

What Is 18 U.S.C. § 1033?

Section 1033 is a federal statute designed to protect the integrity of the insurance industry. It applies to businesses and individuals engaged in insurance activities that affect interstate commerce.

The statute criminalizes:

Making material false statements in financial reports
Overvaluing property or assets to deceive regulators
Embezzlement or misappropriation of insurance company funds
Entering false information into financial records
Threats or force used to influence insurance business activities
Participation in the insurance business after certain felony convictions

Because most insurance companies operate across state lines, federal jurisdiction is often easily established.

What Must Prosecutors Prove?

To secure a conviction under § 1033(a), federal prosecutors must prove:

The defendant was engaged in the business of insurance
The conduct affected interstate commerce
The defendant made a material false statement or report
The statement was made with intent to deceive
The false statement was presented to an insurance regulatory official or relevant authority

Material means the false statement involved an important fact capable of influencing a regulatory decision.

Intent to deceive is a required element. Mistakes or clerical errors are not enough.

Types of Conduct Covered Under 18 U.S.C. § 1033

Material False Statements to Regulators

This includes submitting inaccurate financial reports, overstating assets, or concealing liabilities to influence insurance regulatory agencies.

Embezzlement or Misappropriation

Officers, directors, or employees who steal or misuse insurance company funds may face up to 10 years in federal prison.

False Entries in Records

Knowingly entering materially false financial information into books or records with the intent to deceive.

Threats or Obstruction

Using force or intimidation to unlawfully influence insurance operations affecting interstate commerce.

Lifetime Ban for Certain Felons

Individuals previously convicted of felonies involving dishonesty or breach of trust are prohibited from engaging in the insurance business unless they obtain written regulatory consent.

Penalties for Federal Insurance Fraud

Penalties depend on the subsection violated and the harm caused.

Standard Penalties

Up to 10 years in federal prison
Criminal fines
Supervised release

Enhanced Penalties

Up to 15 years if the conduct jeopardized the insurance company's financial stability
Up to 5 years for prohibited individuals engaging in insurance business

In addition to prison time, defendants may face:

Restitution orders
Professional license revocation
Lifetime industry bans
Civil regulatory actions

Federal insurance fraud convictions can permanently damage professional reputations.

How Federal Insurance Fraud Cases Begin

Investigations often originate from:

State insurance regulators
Internal audits
Whistleblower reports
Financial reporting irregularities
Multi-agency task forces

Federal investigations may involve:

Subpoenas
Grand jury proceedings
Forensic accounting reviews
Search warrants
Interviews with employees

Many targets are unaware they are under investigation until agents make contact.

Interstate Commerce Requirement

Section 1033 applies only when the insurance activity affects interstate commerce.

Because most insurance carriers operate across state lines, this requirement is typically satisfied in federal cases.

Common Defenses to 18 U.S.C. § 1033 Charges

Federal insurance fraud cases are fact-intensive. Potential defenses include:

Lack of Intent

If there was no intent to deceive, criminal liability may not apply.

Not a Material Statement

If the alleged misstatement would not influence a regulatory decision, it may not meet the materiality requirement.

Good Faith Reliance

Reliance on accountants, legal advisors, or internal compliance personnel may be relevant to intent.

No Interstate Commerce Impact

If the government cannot prove interstate impact, federal jurisdiction may be challenged.

Regulatory Consent Exception

For subsection (e) violations, evidence of regulatory approval may defeat the charge.

Early intervention can help shape the investigative narrative before indictment.

Difference Between Federal and State Insurance Fraud

State laws typically address fraudulent insurance claims by policyholders. Federal law under § 1033 focuses more heavily on misconduct within the insurance industry itself.

Federal penalties are generally harsher, and federal sentencing guidelines apply.

Why Federal Defense Experience Matters

Federal insurance fraud cases involve:

Complex financial analysis
Regulatory frameworks
Multi-agency investigations
Potential parallel civil enforcement

Strategic defense may involve:

Early engagement with prosecutors
Negotiating pre-indictment resolutions
Limiting exposure through targeted cooperation
Challenging materiality and intent elements
Presenting mitigation evidence

The earlier counsel becomes involved, the more options may be available.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is insurance fraud always a federal crime?

No. Many cases are prosecuted under state law. Federal jurisdiction applies when the conduct affects interstate commerce and falls within § 1033.

What qualifies as a materially false statement?

A statement that could influence a regulatory decision or affect the financial evaluation of an insurance company.

Can employees be charged personally?

Yes. Officers, directors, agents, and employees can face individual criminal liability.

Does a prior felony prevent working in insurance?

Certain felony convictions involving dishonesty or breach of trust can create a lifetime ban unless regulatory approval is granted.

Can federal insurance fraud charges be resolved without trial?

In some cases, negotiated resolutions or plea agreements may be possible depending on the strength of the evidence.

Contact a Federal Criminal Defense Lawyer

Federal insurance fraud charges under 18 U.S.C. § 1033 carry serious consequences, including lengthy prison sentences and permanent professional consequences.

If you are under investigation or have been charged, you need experienced federal defense counsel immediately.

Eisner Gorin LLP is a nationally recognized criminal defense law firm located in Los Angeles, California. We defend clients nationwide facing complex federal criminal charges.

Contact our office today for a confidential consultation to evaluate your case and protect your future.

Related Content:

Insurance Fraud